Hearing is Believing

Every time I cross 109th St. on my way up or downtown I cast a glance at the apartment building on the corner of 109 and Riverside Drive, the former residence of Hannah Arendt.

Her essays in The New Yorker in 1971 (!) influenced my thinking about teaching and learning so profoundly that I carry their central point in the forefront of my mind.


She confesses that she was never trained to give credence to what she heard, only to what she could see.


So here you are, a piano student, and what you are looking at is clearly identifiable as a major triad in root position. But, as composed by Robert Schumann, it does not sound right, according to that definition. Why? Because he understood that the sound of the piano was a completely new, non-conformist sound. Why? Because it cannot resonate clean, pure overtones.


So he cleverly devised voicing (i.e., where you put each tone of the triad) so that you, whoever you are, would be as intrigued as he was.


Are you? Were you? Or, like me, did you simply turn the page.


www.patreon.com/NancyGarniez Schumann Tutorials every week starting this week, open to the public. Give it a try....What's to lose? Everything to gain.

1 view0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

I remember as a kid being intrigued by the song "Oh, my darlin' Clementine." Sure sounds like a sad story. Can't be! But it is fun to sing it exaggerating its tragic surface. There is a young boy wh

Funny, how we take for granted that someone is listening when we talk to them. Do you recall ever talking to someone who wasn't paying the slightest attention to you and/or to what you were saying? T

No matter how hard instrumentalists try to buy into the notion that tones without words are superior to those with text attached, I say: Watch out! Listen more carefully! We are, after all, human bei